Skip to product information
1 of 4

Super Hot Cheese

Carolina Reaper Cheddar Cheese

Carolina Reaper Cheddar Cheese

Regular price $ 19.99
Regular price $ 19.99 Sale price $ 19.99
Sale Sold out

14 total reviews



Sorry, this product does not qualify for free shipping. All cheese is shipped inside a thermal mailing envelope with an ice pack. We can't ship cheese curds outside the contiguous United States. 

For the most daring cheese and heat lovers only!

This block of high-quality hot pepper-infused cheese is the perfect pairing of cool and creamy world-famous Wisconsin cheddar cheese and fiery throat-burning Carolina Reaper pepper flakes. There is an interesting balance between the two, and only one way to find out if the heat is too much for you.

Enjoy this super spicy cheese on a cracker or sandwich, in a cheese-filled recipe, or on a platter alongside one of our spicy summer sausages. This seriously hot all-natural Reaper cheddar cheese is sure to give your taste buds a massive wake-up call and have you (and anyone you share it with) coming back for more.

This product comes in blocks of various sizes (8-12 ounces). Stock up now before this unique spicy cheddar cheese is all cut and eaten.

Check out our spicy gift baskets for great gift ideas.

Heat Level: Super Hot

Size:  8-12 ounces

Other Flavors:  Be sure to check out our other spicy pepper cheeses including Scorpion CheddarGhost Pepper Jack Cheese, and Ghost Cheese Curds.

Looking to grow your own Carolina Reaper peppers?  Check out our Reaper pepper seeds and Carolina Reaper pepper plant.

Shipping & Returns:

Free shipping on orders of $35 or more (excludes cheese and Canada orders). We ship to US and Canada addresses only. Please note: additional shipping charge of $8.99 for all cheese orders. For more information, please visit our Shipping & Returns page.

Our Guarantee:

If for any reason you are not 100% satisfied with your order, please contact us. If you’re not happy, we’re not happy and we’ll work to make it right.

View full details

Customer Reviews

Based on 14 reviews
Carolina Reaper Cheddar Cheese

This is great cheese if you like it hot! I do

Robert Smothers

It was Amazing

Kevin C Delaney
Wonderful flavor, beautiful heat!

Wonderful flavor, beautiful heat! What else can one say about this cheese when paired with Summer sausage.

Yolanda Hall
Too Hot....

The sausage is tasty but waayyyyyy too hot. Please refund or send a milder level than Carolina Reaper. If you want to lose all function of your bowels this is the version for you, I bought the cheese too.... I will shred and try to mix in "very sparingly".

Jeff Wurster

Carolina Reaper Cheddar Cheese