Spicy Cheese

NOTE: Spicy cheeses are not available until Fall, or when cooler temperatures allow us to safely ship these temperature-sensitive items. If you haven't already, please sign up for our email newsletter or SMS group to be notified first when they are back in stock!

Refrigerated products only ship Monday - Wednesday due to long transit times and warm weather.

We've all been there. You get the late-night cheese cravings and you need cheese to keep you sane. Well, we're diehard cheese lovers but we wanted to find a way to infuse hot peppers like Mango Habaneros and Carolina Reapers into our high-quality Wisconsin cheddar cheese because we're that crazy. It's a good thing we're crazy because we're bringing you the hottest cheese you'll ever try! Try our spicy cheddar cheese to make scrumptious food like spicy mac and cheese and pepper poppers, or gift a cheese lover!